Methodology - Charities Rating Explained

The application process begins with a Web-based, self-administered questionnaire.

The application starts by screening for eligibility on two key criteria - the type of funding received (government vs. private) and whether the charity serves individuals.

Then the questionnaire gathers information on four primary categories:

  1. How well the program evaluates outcomes or results;
  2. How well the program fosters personal change in the individuals served;
  3. To what extent spirituality is incorporated into programming; and
  4. How well the program implements the seven principles of effective compassion, as formulated by author Marvin Olasky,
    • Affiliation
    • Bonding
    • Categorization
    • Discernment
    • Employment
    • Freedom
    • God (Spirituality)

The answers are weighted based on Samaritan Award priorities to produce an overall score. The algorithm used was developed in conjunction with social science researchers, who also score all applications. The organizations with the top combined scores become the finalists.

Along with an overall score, scores are calculated for each of the four categories listed above. The scores are plotted against all other applicants, allowing organizations to compare themselves with other organizations. This information can help charities seeking to improve their performance and help donors match their philanthropy with their interests.

Samaritan Guide